
I have not been able to get the
House in the Night out of my head since the Caldecott announcement was made yesterday morning. Not, mind you, because it was a fantastic book with illustrations that just swept me away, but rather because I do not see how the book won the top honors! To me, a better choice would have been
In a Blue Room by Jim Averbeck, if they really wanted a bedtime book to win.
This isn't the first time I have felt this way, so I am beginning to think that perhaps my mind just doesn't work the way an able-to-give-top-honors judge's mind works. Or maybe there is something else going on.
I'm just not a fan of awards - shows, books or otherwise. Yes, I am cynical. I believe most awards can be bought. I've also known a few people who have participated on top award committees and know that they have "agendas" - books they want to win. Well, don't we all have our favorites?! But if you get on a committee with like minded individuals, there just might be a lot of wonderful items neglected.

Two titles that come to mind are
Old Bear by Kevin Henkes and
The Little Yellow Leaf by Carin Berger. Both are timeless tales with illustrations that really speak for the text and stick with you.
We Are the Ship: The Story of Negro League Baseball is yet another title that has strong images, not to mention a text that is both enjoyable and interesting to read, illustrating how Kadir Nelson's storytelling ability just draws in the reader as much as his beautiful images do.
Books are rather personal, and each title that is drawn up into a person's hands is interpreted differently by those who seek to absorb the message inside. Maybe the Caldecott people were right and
The House in the Night is the absolute best picture book to come out of 2008, or maybe there are many others out there worthy of your attention too.